As a beauty blogger, the festive season is always a great time to test out new makeup products. With holiday events, family dinners, and New Year celebrations, I had the perfect opportunity to try the Wunderbrow Super Stay Liner which I purchased direct from Wunderbrow over the Christmas 2024 period. Promising a smudge-proof, waterproof, long-lasting formula, I put this eyeliner through its paces during busy days, evenings out, and even quiet work-from-home moments.
First Impressions
The Wunderbrow Super Stay Liner comes in a sleek, no-fuss pencil that’s easy to use and travel-friendly. The twist-up design eliminates the need for sharpening, making it convenient to toss in a bag and take on the go. I opted for the black shade, a classic choice to suit a range of looks from subtle daytime definition to bold evening glam.
The first thing I noticed was how creamy the formula felt—it glided on effortlessly without tugging at my skin. Despite the softness, it offered intense pigmentation, delivering a rich, deep black with just one stroke. Its versatility made it ideal for experimenting with different styles.
Christmas Week: Family Gatherings and Festivities
Christmas Eve
I started my trial on Christmas Eve with a family dinner at home. I wanted a soft, natural look, so I used the liner to lightly define my lash line. The creamy texture made it easy to blend with a small smudging brush, creating a smoky, effortless effect. Even after a long evening of cooking and mingling, the liner stayed put—no smudges, no fading.
Christmas Day Dinner
On Christmas Day, we headed to a local pub for a festive family meal. For this occasion, I went for a winged eyeliner look to complement a sparkly holiday dress. The precise tip allowed me to create a clean, sharp flick, and the rich pigment required no layering. Despite the warmth of the pub and the hours spent laughing and eating, the liner held its ground. By the end of the evening, it still looked as fresh as when I applied it.
Quiet Work-from-Home Days
The week between Christmas and New Year was much quieter, giving me the chance to use the liner in my daily work-from-home routine. For a minimal makeup look, I simply applied it along my upper lash line for subtle definition. Even after hours of staring at screens and a quick midday workout, the liner didn’t budge.
One downside I noticed during this time was that the twist-up pencil seemed to wear down quickly with frequent use. While this wasn’t a major issue, it’s something to consider for those who plan to use it daily.
New Year’s Day Lunch
To kick off 2025, I wore the liner to a celebratory New Year’s Day lunch with friends and family. Pairing it with a bold red lip, I went for a dramatic, cat-eye look. The liner’s creamy formula made it easy to create the extended flick, and it dried quickly, ensuring no accidental smudges as I perfected the shape.
After hours of chatting, toasting, and enjoying hearty winter dishes, the liner remained flawless. Its waterproof claim held true, even against the occasional misty drizzle as we walked to the restaurant.
Performance Recap
Positives:
- Rich Pigment: Delivers bold, intense colour in a single stroke.
- Creamy Texture: Glides on smoothly without tugging, making it perfect for precise lines or smudged looks.
- Long-Lasting Formula: Truly lives up to its smudge-proof and waterproof claims, staying put through meals, misty weather, and long hours.
- Versatile: Works well for a range of styles, from natural to bold.
Negatives:
- Quick Wear-Down: The pencil tip wears down faster than expected with frequent use, meaning you may go through it more quickly.
- Not Ideal for Tightlining: While great for the lash line, its creamy texture might transfer slightly when used for tightlining.
Final Thoughts
The Wunderbrow Super Stay Liner is an excellent choice for anyone seeking a reliable, high-performing eyeliner. From casual daytime looks to full-glam holiday events, it held up beautifully in every scenario I put it through. While its longevity and pigment are standout features, the slightly quicker wear of the twist-up pencil might be a consideration for daily use.
Disclaimer: This review is based on my personal experience using the Wunderbrow Super Stay Liner over the Christmas 2024 period. Individual results may vary based on skin type, application style, and daily routine. If you’re in the market for a versatile, long-lasting eyeliner, this one is definitely worth a try.